"But
he didn't even mention anime!", those dear readers of mine who
have actually read Zinsser's book might say. Well, yes, he didn't.
But he did talk about reviewing the popular arts, and last time I
checked, anime falls under that category with film, television, and
books.
Note:
I'm not saying these should be absolute rules about anime blogging,
since everyone blogs their own way. And some of them are more refresher points than brand new revelations. But these are pointers that can be helpful to the process. Although you might think this post
rather rich of me since I do not blog anime as often as others ...
Yeah,
you can review Madoka Magica without watching Sailor Moon or Card
Captor Sakura or Utena. And you can review Gundam 00 without watching
Wing or 008th MS Team or Seed. And you can definitely review a Studio
Ghibli film without having seen all the ones before it. But that
doesn't mean you can just vastly underestimate the importance of what
has come before.
I'm
not saying you have to watch every anime ever made. That's insane;
anime is just too huge a medium, sub-genres inside of sub-genres, and
quite frankly no one has time for that. But every genre, every
director, every studio has their respective oeuvre and when you pluck
one work out for review, you're plucking it out of a time line of
works still in progress, each work impacting the one after it. It's
nice to acknowledge that in your review, somehow.
Plus,
don't automatically discount an upcoming work just because it's new.
Every new anime is potentially bringing something new to the medium.
I'd rather be excited about new things coming out every season that
permanently dour about the state of anime. Yes, even if its moeblob
nonsense. Hey - I did unironically enjoy NakaImo in the end, didn't
I?
2.
Don't give away the whole story.
Not pictured: that scene where [redacted] does [redacted]. |
So
imagine if I wrote a review of the Akira film and gave away every
major plot twist and nuance in my post. Imagine if I did that with
any anime series. You could still watch the series - but the surprise
would be gone, and you'd be expecting every twist I'd already told
you about. You can probably give a good summary of the story in one
paragraph and make it intriguing enough without giving the whole plot
away.
Unless
it doesn't have a plot. In which case, I can't really help you.
Note:
this does not really apply to reviewing a series episode by episode.
I expect that people reading a review of Bleach's 300th episode knows
what is going on and probably watched the episode being talked about.
Slap a spoiler warning on it if you want and leave it be.
3. Stand by your opinion or don't state it at all.
3. Stand by your opinion or don't state it at all.
Anime
blogging is a contemptuous business. People will disagree with you
every day, whether you hate their favorite anime or love their least
favorite anime or just say something that simply doesn't jive with
their own way of thinking. And you know what? It doesn't matter. You
can't change everyone's mind and that shouldn't be the point of your
anime blogging.
YOU TELL THEM, random Reddit meme. |
So
yes, the beginning half of the Saiyuki manga has mediocre
storytelling. NakaImo is not a terrible series, and it's a lot better
than a series that is pretentious and takes itself way too seriously
(Guilty Crown, sup). Yoko Kanno's discography is way more diverse
than Yuki Kajiura but they are both equally talented. Viz Media's
IKKI is the best English language manga imprint you're not reading.
Be
frank, be open, be honest. And yes, be polite about it - but if
you're gonna stir shit in the anime blogosphere, at least stand by
your immense shit stirring and own it.
All
right. What things about anime blogging have you learned during these
recent years?
No comments:
Post a Comment